7657
Comment: why IFS=$'\n' backfires
|
7574
Added link to trimming section.
|
Deletions are marked like this. | Additions are marked like this. |
Line 2: | Line 2: |
== How can I read a file (data stream, variable) line-by-line? == Use a `while` loop and the `read` command: |
== How can I read a file (data stream, variable) line-by-line (and/or field-by-field)? == [[DontReadLinesWithFor|Don't try to use "for"]]. Use a `while` loop and the `read` command: |
Line 7: | Line 6: |
while read -r line | while IFS= read -r line |
Line 12: | Line 11: |
The `-r` option to read prevents backslash interpretation (usually used as a backslash newline pair, to continue over multiple lines). Without this option, any backslashes in the input will be discarded. You should always use the `-r` option with read. | The `-r` option to `read` prevents backslash interpretation (usually used as a backslash newline pair, to continue over multiple lines). Without this option, any backslashes in the input will be discarded. You should always use the `-r` option with read. |
Line 14: | Line 13: |
[[BASH]] can also iterate over the lines in a variable using a "here string": | `IFS=` prevents trimming of leading and trailing whitespace, see [[#Trimming|below.]] `line` is a variable name, chosen by you. You can use any valid shell variable name there. The [[BashGuide/InputAndOutput#Redirection|redirection]] `< "$file"` tells the `while` loop to read from the file whose name is in the variable `file`. If you would prefer to use a literal pathname instead of a variable, you may do that as well. If your input source is the script's standard input, then you don't need any redirection at all. If your input source is the contents of a variable/parameter, [[BASH]] can iterate over its lines using a "here string": |
Line 21: | Line 26: |
If your data source is the script's standard input, then you don't need any redirection at all. | The same can be done in any Bourne-type shell by using a "here document" (although `read -r` is POSIX, not Bourne): {{{ while read -r line; do echo "$line" done <<EOF $var EOF }}} If avoiding comments starting with `#` is desired, you can simply skip them inside the loop: {{{ # Bash while read -r line do [[ $line = \#* ]] && continue echo "$line" done < "$file" }}} |
Line 31: | Line 55: |
If the field delimiters are not whitespace, you can set {{{IFS}}} (input field separator): | If the field delimiters are not whitespace, you can set [[IFS|IFS (internal field separator)]]: |
Line 38: | Line 63: |
For TAB delimited files, use IFS=$'\t'. | For tab-delimited files, use [[Quotes|IFS=$'\t']]. |
Line 40: | Line 65: |
Also, please note that you do ''not'' necessarily need to know how many fields each line of input contains. If you supply more variables than there are fields, the extra variables will be empty. If you supply fewer, the last variable gets "all the rest" of the fields after the preceding ones are satisfied. For example, | You do ''not'' necessarily need to know how many fields each line of input contains. If you supply more variables than there are fields, the extra variables will be empty. If you supply fewer, the last variable gets "all the rest" of the fields after the preceding ones are satisfied. For example, |
Line 43: | Line 68: |
while read -r first_name last_name junk; do ... done <<< 'Bob Smith 123 Main Street Elk Grove Iowa 123-555-6789' # Inside the loop, first_name will contain "Bob", and # last_name will contain "Smith". The variable "junk" holds # everything else. |
read -r first last junk <<< 'Bob Smith 123 Main Street Elk Grove Iowa 123-555-6789' # first will contain "Bob", and last will contain "Smith". # junk holds everything else. |
Line 50: | Line 73: |
The {{{read}}} command modifies each line read, e.g. by default it removes all leading whitespace characters (blanks, tab characters, ... -- basically any leading characters present in IFS). If that is not desired, the {{{IFS}}} variable has to be cleared: | Some people use the throwaway variable `_` as a "junk variable" to ignore fields. It (or indeed any variable) can also be used more than once in a single `read` command, if we don't care what goes into it: |
Line 53: | Line 77: |
read -r _ _ first middle last _ <<< "$record" # We skip the first two fields, then read the next three. # Remember, the final _ can absorb any number of fields. # It doesn't need to be repeated there. }}} <<Anchor(Trimming)>>The {{{read}}} command modifies each line read; by default it [[BashFAQ/067|removes all leading and trailing whitespace]] characters (spaces and tabs, or any whitespace characters present in [[IFS]]). If that is not desired, the {{{IFS}}} variable has to be cleared: {{{ # Exact lines, no trimming |
|
Line 55: | Line 90: |
echo "$line" | printf '%s\n' "$line" |
Line 58: | Line 93: |
'''Note that reading a file line by line this way is ''very slow'' for large files. Consider using e.g. [[AWK]] instead if you get performance problems.''' | |
Line 67: | Line 101: |
This method is especially useful for processing the output of `find` with a block of commands: | This method is especially useful for processing the output of [[UsingFind|find]] with a block of commands: |
Line 70: | Line 104: |
find . -print0 | while IFS= read -r -d $'\0' file; do | find . -type f -print0 | while IFS= read -r -d '' file; do |
Line 74: | Line 108: |
This command reads one filename at a time from the file command and renames the file so that its spaces are replaced by underscores. | This reads one filename at a time from the `find` command and [[BashFAQ/030|renames the file]], replacing spaces with underscores. |
Line 76: | Line 110: |
Note the usage of {{{-print0}}} in the find command, which uses NUL bytes as filename delimiters, and {{{-d $'\0'}}} in the read command to instruct it to read all text into the file variable until it finds a NUL byte. By default, `find` and `read` delimit their input with newlines; however, since filenames can potentially contain newlines themselves, this default behaviour will split up those filenames with newlines and cause the loop body to fail. Additionally it is necessary to unset IFS, because otherwise read would strip trailing whitespace. See [[BashFAQ/020|FAQ #20]] for more details. | Note the usage of `-print0` in the `find` command, which uses NUL bytes as filename delimiters; and {{{-d ''}}} in the `read` command to instruct it to read all text into the `file` variable until it finds a NUL byte. By default, `find` and `read` delimit their input with newlines; however, since filenames can potentially contain newlines themselves, this default behaviour will split up those filenames at the newlines and cause the loop body to fail. Additionally it is necessary to set `IFS` to an empty string, because otherwise `read` would still strip leading and trailing whitespace. See [[BashFAQ/020|FAQ #20]] for more details. |
Line 78: | Line 112: |
Using a pipe to send find's output into a while loop places the loop in a SubShell and may therefore cause problems later on if the commands inside the body of the loop attempt to set variables which need to be used outside the loop; in that case, see [[BashFAQ/024|FAQ 24]], or use ProcessSubstitution like: | Using a pipe to send `find`'s output into a while loop places the loop in a SubShell and may therefore cause problems later on if the commands inside the body of the loop attempt to set variables which need to be used after the loop; in that case, see [[BashFAQ/024|FAQ 24]], or use a ProcessSubstitution like: |
Line 85: | Line 119: |
Sometimes it's useful to read a file into an [[BashFAQ/005|array]], one array element per line. You can do that with the following example: | If you want to read lines from a file into an [[BashFAQ/005|array]], see [[BashFAQ/005|FAQ 5]]. === My text files are broken! They lack their final newlines! === If there are some characters after the last line in the file (or to put it differently, if the last line is not terminated by a newline character), then `read` will read it but return false, leaving the broken partial line in the `read` variable(s). You can process this after the loop: |
Line 88: | Line 127: |
oIFS=$IFS IFS=$'\n' arr=($(< myfile)) IFS=$oIFS # Warning: breaks if lines contain "*" or similar |
# Emulate cat while IFS= read -r line do printf '%s\n' "$line" done < "$file" [ -n "$line" ] && printf %s "$line" |
Line 91: | Line 134: |
This temporarily changes the Input Field Separator to a newline, so that each line will be considered one field by read. Then it populates the array {{{arr}}} with the fields. Then it sets the {{{IFS}}} back to what it was before. | |
Line 93: | Line 135: |
This same trick works on a stream of data as well as a file: {{{ oIFS=$IFS IFS=$'\n' arr=($(find . -type f)) IFS=$oIFS # Same warning as the previous example }}} Of course, this will blow up in your face if the filenames contain newlines; see [[BashFAQ/020|FAQ 20]] for hints on dealing with such filenames. Both of these array-stuffing examples fail if the shell encounters a [[glob]] that matches files in the current directory as one of the input lines. Glob expansion can be disabled with `set -f` and then re-enabled afterward with `set +f` if needed. For more details on arrays, see [[BashFAQ/005|FAQ 5]]. Moreover, since bash will treat sequences of IFS whitespace as a single character, if the input has empty lines (meaning that groups of two or more consecutive \n characters appear in the file), they will be lost. So, for example: {{{ $ cat myfile line1 line2 line3 $ oIFS=$IFS IFS=$'\n' arr=($(< myfile)) IFS=$oIFS $ declare -p arr declare -a arr='([0]="line1" [1]="line2" [2]="line3")' }}} In the end, the safest way to read a file into an array is still to use a loop: {{{ i=0 while IFS= read -r arr[i++]; do :;done < "$file" # or <<< "$var" to iterate over a variable }}} On the other hand, if the file lacks a trailing newline (such as {{{/proc/$$/cmdline}}} on Linux), the line will not be printed by a {{{while read ...}}} loop, as {{{read}}} returns a failure that aborts the while loop, thus failing to print the ultimate line. It does, however, store the contents of the partial line in the variable, so you can test whether there was such an unterminated line by checking whether the variable is non-empty at the end of the loop: |
Or: |
Line 124: | Line 139: |
echo -en 'line 1\ntruncated line 2' | while read -r line; do echo $line; done | printf 'line 1\ntruncated line 2' | while read -r line; do echo $line; done |
Line 127: | Line 142: |
echo -en 'line 1\ntruncated line 2' | while read -r line; do echo "$line"; done; [[ $line ]] && echo -n "$line" | printf 'line 1\ntruncated line 2' | while read -r line; do echo "$line"; done; [[ $line ]] && echo -n "$line" |
Line 130: | Line 145: |
echo -en 'line 1\ntruncated line 2' | (while read -r line; do echo "$line"; done; [[ $line ]] && echo "$line") | printf 'line 1\ntruncated line 2' | (while read -r line; do echo "$line"; done; [[ $line ]] && echo "$line") |
Line 134: | Line 149: |
=== Using for instead of while read === | === How to keep other commands from "eating" the input === Some commands greedily eat up all available data on standard input. The examples above do not take precautions against such programs. For example, {{{ while read -r line do cat > ignoredfile echo "$line" done < "$file" }}} will only print the contents of the first line, with the remaining contents going to "ignoredfile", as `cat` slurps up all available input. |
Line 136: | Line 160: |
Using {{{for}}} instead of {{{while read ...}}} is generally less efficient and more "featureful": | One workaround is to use a numeric FileDescriptor rather than standard input: {{{ # Bash while read -r -u9 line do cat > ignoredfile echo "$line" done 9< "$file" }}} Or: |
Line 139: | Line 173: |
$ cat afile ef gh * $ while read i ; do echo "$i" ; done < afile ef gh * $ for i in $(<afile) ; do echo "$i" ; done ef gh afile # the glob was expanded, and it looped per word. #workaround: $ IFS=$'\n' ;set -f ; for i in $(<afile) ; do echo "$i" ; done ef gh * |
# Bourne exec 9< "$file" while read line <&9 do ... done exec 9<&- |
Line 159: | Line 182: |
However, as discussed in [[BashFAQ/005|FAQ #5]], the use of `IFS=$'\n'` (or any other "whitespace" in `IFS`) causes the shell to consolidate all consecutive instances of the whitespace delimiter into one. In other words, it skips over blank lines. Thus, | This example will wait for the user to type something into the file {{{ignoredfile}}} at each iteration instead of eating up the loop input. |
Line 161: | Line 184: |
{{{ ~$ cat foo line one |
You might need this, for example, with `mencoder` which will accept user input if there is any, but will continue silently if there isn't. Other commands that act this way include `ssh` and `ffmpeg`. Additional workarounds for this are discussed in [[BashFAQ/089|FAQ #89]]. |
Line 165: | Line 186: |
line three ~$ IFS=$'\n'; set -f; for line in $(<foo); do echo "$line"; done; unset IFS; set +f line one line three ~$ }}} If preservation of blank lines is important, just go back to using `while read`. |
---- CategoryShell |
How can I read a file (data stream, variable) line-by-line (and/or field-by-field)?
Don't try to use "for". Use a while loop and the read command:
while IFS= read -r line do echo "$line" done < "$file"
The -r option to read prevents backslash interpretation (usually used as a backslash newline pair, to continue over multiple lines). Without this option, any backslashes in the input will be discarded. You should always use the -r option with read.
IFS= prevents trimming of leading and trailing whitespace, see below.
line is a variable name, chosen by you. You can use any valid shell variable name there.
The redirection < "$file" tells the while loop to read from the file whose name is in the variable file. If you would prefer to use a literal pathname instead of a variable, you may do that as well. If your input source is the script's standard input, then you don't need any redirection at all.
If your input source is the contents of a variable/parameter, BASH can iterate over its lines using a "here string":
while read -r line; do echo "$line" done <<< "$var"
The same can be done in any Bourne-type shell by using a "here document" (although read -r is POSIX, not Bourne):
while read -r line; do echo "$line" done <<EOF $var EOF
If avoiding comments starting with # is desired, you can simply skip them inside the loop:
# Bash while read -r line do [[ $line = \#* ]] && continue echo "$line" done < "$file"
If you want to operate on individual fields within each line, you may supply additional variables to read:
# Input file has 3 columns separated by white space. while read -r first_name last_name phone; do ... done < "$file"
If the field delimiters are not whitespace, you can set IFS (internal field separator):
while IFS=: read -r user pass uid gid gecos home shell; do ... done < /etc/passwd
For tab-delimited files, use IFS=$'\t'.
You do not necessarily need to know how many fields each line of input contains. If you supply more variables than there are fields, the extra variables will be empty. If you supply fewer, the last variable gets "all the rest" of the fields after the preceding ones are satisfied. For example,
read -r first last junk <<< 'Bob Smith 123 Main Street Elk Grove Iowa 123-555-6789' # first will contain "Bob", and last will contain "Smith". # junk holds everything else.
Some people use the throwaway variable _ as a "junk variable" to ignore fields. It (or indeed any variable) can also be used more than once in a single read command, if we don't care what goes into it:
read -r _ _ first middle last _ <<< "$record" # We skip the first two fields, then read the next three. # Remember, the final _ can absorb any number of fields. # It doesn't need to be repeated there.
The read command modifies each line read; by default it removes all leading and trailing whitespace characters (spaces and tabs, or any whitespace characters present in IFS). If that is not desired, the IFS variable has to be cleared:
# Exact lines, no trimming while IFS= read -r line do printf '%s\n' "$line" done < "$file"
One may also read from a command instead of a regular file:
some command | while read -r line; do other commands done
This method is especially useful for processing the output of find with a block of commands:
find . -type f -print0 | while IFS= read -r -d '' file; do mv "$file" "${file// /_}" done
This reads one filename at a time from the find command and renames the file, replacing spaces with underscores.
Note the usage of -print0 in the find command, which uses NUL bytes as filename delimiters; and -d '' in the read command to instruct it to read all text into the file variable until it finds a NUL byte. By default, find and read delimit their input with newlines; however, since filenames can potentially contain newlines themselves, this default behaviour will split up those filenames at the newlines and cause the loop body to fail. Additionally it is necessary to set IFS to an empty string, because otherwise read would still strip leading and trailing whitespace. See FAQ #20 for more details.
Using a pipe to send find's output into a while loop places the loop in a SubShell and may therefore cause problems later on if the commands inside the body of the loop attempt to set variables which need to be used after the loop; in that case, see FAQ 24, or use a ProcessSubstitution like:
while read -r line; do other commands done < <(some command)
If you want to read lines from a file into an array, see FAQ 5.
My text files are broken! They lack their final newlines!
If there are some characters after the last line in the file (or to put it differently, if the last line is not terminated by a newline character), then read will read it but return false, leaving the broken partial line in the read variable(s). You can process this after the loop:
# Emulate cat while IFS= read -r line do printf '%s\n' "$line" done < "$file" [ -n "$line" ] && printf %s "$line"
Or:
# This does not work: printf 'line 1\ntruncated line 2' | while read -r line; do echo $line; done # This does not work either: printf 'line 1\ntruncated line 2' | while read -r line; do echo "$line"; done; [[ $line ]] && echo -n "$line" # This works: printf 'line 1\ntruncated line 2' | (while read -r line; do echo "$line"; done; [[ $line ]] && echo "$line")
For a discussion of why the second example above does not work as expected, see FAQ #24.
How to keep other commands from "eating" the input
Some commands greedily eat up all available data on standard input. The examples above do not take precautions against such programs. For example,
while read -r line do cat > ignoredfile echo "$line" done < "$file"
will only print the contents of the first line, with the remaining contents going to "ignoredfile", as cat slurps up all available input.
One workaround is to use a numeric FileDescriptor rather than standard input:
# Bash while read -r -u9 line do cat > ignoredfile echo "$line" done 9< "$file"
Or:
# Bourne exec 9< "$file" while read line <&9 do ... done exec 9<&-
This example will wait for the user to type something into the file ignoredfile at each iteration instead of eating up the loop input.
You might need this, for example, with mencoder which will accept user input if there is any, but will continue silently if there isn't. Other commands that act this way include ssh and ffmpeg. Additional workarounds for this are discussed in FAQ #89.