Differences between revisions 4 and 5
Revision 4 as of 2008-11-22 14:08:28
Size: 1798
Editor: localhost
Comment: converted to 1.6 markup
Revision 5 as of 2008-11-22 21:59:16
Size: 1803
Editor: GreyCat
Comment: first-line -- indicate that there IS more to the answer
Deletions are marked like this. Additions are marked like this.
Line 3: Line 3:
The answer is, basically, no. The answer is, basically, no....
Line 21: Line 21:

Can bash handle binary data?

The answer is, basically, no....

While bash won't have as many problems with it as older shells, it still can't process arbitrary binary data, and more specifically, shell variables are not 100% binary clean, so you can't store binary files in them.

One instance where such would sometimes be handy is storing small temporary bitmaps while working with netpbm... here I resorted to adding an extra pnmnoraw to the pipe, creating (larger) ASCII files that bash has no problems storing).

If you are feeling adventurous, consider this experiment:

    # bindec.bash, attempt to decode binary data to ascii decimals
    while read -n1 x ;do
        case "$x" in
            '') echo empty ;;
            # insert the 256 lines generated by the following oneliner here:
            # for x in $(seq 0 255) ;do echo "        $'\\$(printf %o $x)') echo $x;;" ;done

and then pipe binary data into it, maybe like so:

    for x in $(seq 0 255) ;do echo -ne "\\$(printf %o $x)" ;done | bash bindec.bash | nl | less

This suggests that the 0 character is skipped entirely, because we can't create it with the input generation, enough to conveniently corrupt most binary files we try to process.

  • Yes, Bash is written in C, and uses C semantics for handling strings -- including the NUL byte as string terminator -- in its variables. You cannot store NUL in a Bash variable sanely. It simply was never intended to be used for this. - GreyCat

Note that this refers to storing them in variables... moving data between programs using pipes is always binary clean. Temporary files are also safe, as long as appropriate precautions are taken when creating them.

BashFAQ/058 (last edited 2009-03-09 08:26:26 by pgas)