Differences between revisions 75 and 108 (spanning 33 versions)
Revision 75 as of 2013-03-14 14:15:08
Size: 11790
Editor: Lhunath
Comment: no need to check for --.
Revision 108 as of 2016-11-19 14:40:01
Size: 7105
Editor: 213-211-57-37
Comment: Added mention about the Argbash utility (incorporated feedback from geirha)
Deletions are marked like this. Additions are marked like this.
Line 1: Line 1:
#pragma section-numbers 3
Line 9: Line 8:
This approach handles any arbitrary set of options, because you're writing the parser yourself. For 90% of programs, this is the simplest approach (because you rarely need fancy stuff). Manually parsing options without the use of a specialized function is the most flexible approach, and is sufficient for most simple scripts.
Line 11: Line 10:
This example will handle a combination of short and long options. Notice how both "--file" and "--file=FILE" are handled. This example will handle a combination of short (POSIX) and long "GNU style" options with option arguments. Notice how both `--file FILE` and `--file=FILE` are handled. Typical scripts may also use functions and local variables, which can greatly improve your code. This example however illustrates a strictly POSIX conforming script.
Line 15: Line 14:
# (POSIX shell syntax) # POSIX
Line 18: Line 17:
file=""
verbose=0
file=
verbose=0 # Variables to be evaluated as shell arithmetic should be initialized to a default or validated beforehand.
Line 21: Line 20:
while :
do
while :; do
Line 24: Line 22:
        -h | --help | -\?)
            # Call your Help() or usage() function here.
            exit 0 # This is not an error, User asked help. Don't do "exit 1"
        -h|-\?|--help) # Call a "show_help" function to display a synopsis, then exit.
            show_help
            exit
Line 28: Line 26:
        -f | --file)
            file=$2 # You might want to check if you really got FILE
            shift 2
        -f|--file) # Takes an option argument, ensuring it has been specified.
            if [ -n "$2" ]; then
                file=$2
                shift
            else
                printf 'ERROR: "--file" requires a non-empty option argument.\n' >&2
                exit 1
            fi
Line 32: Line 35:
        --file=*)
            file=${1#*=}        # Delete everything up till "="
        shift
        --file=?*)
            file=${1#*=} # Delete everything up to "=" and assign the remainder.
Line 36: Line 38:
        -v | --verbose)
            # Each instance of -v adds 1 to verbosity
            verbose=$((verbose+1))
            shift
        --file=) # Handle the case of an empty --file=
            printf 'ERROR: "--file" requires a non-empty option argument.\n' >&2
            exit 1
Line 41: Line 42:
        --) # End of all options         -v|--verbose)
            verbose=$((verbose + 1)) # Each -v argument adds 1 to verbosity.
            ;;
        --) # End of all options.
Line 45: Line 49:
        -*)
            echo "WARN: Unknown option (ignored): $1" >&2
            shift
        -?*)
            printf 'WARN: Unknown option (ignored): %s\n' "$1" >&2
Line 49: Line 52:
        *) # no more options. Stop while loop         *)              # Default case: If no more options then break out of the loop.
Line 51: Line 54:
            ;;
Line 53: Line 55:

    shift
Line 55: Line 59:
# Suppose some options are required. Check that we got them.

if [ ! "$file" ]; then
    echo "ERROR: option '--file FILE' not given. See --help" >&2
    exit 1
# if --file was provided, open it for writing, else duplicate stdout
if [ -n "$file" ]; then
    exec 3> "$file"
else
    exec 3>&1
Line 68: Line 72:
Some Bash programmers like to write this at the beginning of their scripts to guard against unused variables:

{{{
    set -u # or, set -o nounset
}}}
The use of this breaks the loop above, as "$1" may not be set upon entering the loop. There are four solutions to this issue:

 1. Stop using `-u`.
 1. Replace `case $1 in` with `case ${1+$1} in` (as well as bandaging all the other code that `set -u` breaks).
 1. Replace `case $1 in` with `case ${1-} in` (every potentially undeclared variable could be written as ${variable-} to prevent `set -u` tripping).
 1. Stop using `-u`.
Line 81: Line 73:
'''Never use getopt(1).''' `getopt` cannot handle empty arguments strings, or arguments with embedded whitespace. Please forget that it ever existed. Unless it's the version from util-linux, and you use its advanced mode, '''never use getopt(1).''' Traditional versions of `getopt` cannot handle empty argument strings, or arguments with embedded whitespace.
Line 88: Line 80:
# Usage info
show_help() {
cat << EOF
Usage: ${0##*/} [-hv] [-f OUTFILE] [FILE]...
Do stuff with FILE and write the result to standard output. With no FILE
or when FILE is -, read standard input.

    -h display this help and exit
    -f OUTFILE write the result to OUTFILE instead of standard output.
    -v verbose mode. Can be used multiple times for increased
                verbosity.
EOF
}
Line 92: Line 98:
OPTIND=1 # Reset is necessary if getopts was used previously in the script.  It is a good idea to make this local in a function.
while getopts "h?vf:" opt; do
OPTIND=1
# Resetting OPTIND is necessary if getopts was used previously in the script.
#
It is a good idea to make OPTIND local if you process options in a function.

while getopts "hvf:" opt; do
Line 95: Line 104:
        h|\?)         h)
Line 99: Line 108:
        v) verbose=1         v) verbose=$((verbose+1))
Line 103: Line 112:
        '?')
            show_help >&2
            exit 1
            ;;
Line 105: Line 118:
shift $((OPTIND-1)) # Shift off the options and optional --. shift "$((OPTIND-1))" # Shift off the options and optional --.
Line 107: Line 120:
echo "verbose=$verbose, output_file='$output_file', Leftovers: $@" # Everything that's left in "$@" is a non-option. In our case, a FILE to process.
printf 'verbose=<%d>\noutput_file=<%s>\nLeftovers:\n' "$verbose" "$output_file"
printf '<%s>\n' "$@"
Line 111: Line 126:
The advantages of `getopts` are:

 1. It's portable, and will work in e.g. dash.
 1. It can handle things like `-vf filename` in the expected Unix way, automatically.

The disadvantage of `getopts` is that it can only handle short options (`-h`, not `--help`) without trickery.
Line 120: Line 129:
There is also still the disadvantage that options are coded in at least 2, probably 3 places - in the call to `getopts`, in the case statement that processes them and presumably in the help message that you are going to get around to writing one of these days. This is a classic opportunity for errors to creep in as the code is written and maintained - often not discovered till much, much later. This can be avoided by using callback functions, but this approach kind of defeats the purpose of using getopts at all. The advantages of `getopts`:
Line 122: Line 131:
==== getops long option trickery ====
Here is an example which claims to parse long options with `getopts`. The basic idea is quite simple: just put "-:" into the optstring. This trick requires a shell which permits the option-argument (i.e. the filename in "-f filename") to be concatenated to the option (as in "-ffilename"). The [[http://pubs.opengroup.org/onlinepubs/9699919799/utilities/getopts.html|POSIX standard]] says there must be a space between them; bash and dash permit the "-ffilename" variant, but one should not rely on this leniency if attempting to write a portable script.
 1. It's portable, and will work in any POSIX shell e.g. dash.
 1. It can handle things like `-vf filename` in the expected Unix way, automatically.
 1. It understands `--` as the option terminator and more generally makes sure, options are parsed like for any standard command.
 1. With some implementations, the error messages will be localised in the language of the user.
Line 125: Line 136:
{{{#!highlight bash
#!/bin/bash
# Uses bash extensions. Not portable as written.
The disadvantages of `getopts`:
 1. (Except for ksh93 `getopts`) it can only handle short options (`-h`, not `--help`) without trickery.
 1. It cannot handle options with optional arguments à la GNU.
 1. Options are coded in at least 2, probably 3 places -- in the call to `getopts`, in the case statement that processes them, and in the help/usage message that documents them.
Line 129: Line 141:
optspec=":h-:" For other, more complicated ways of option parsing, see ComplexOptionParsing.
Line 131: Line 143:
while getopts "$optspec" optchar
do
    case "${optchar}" in
        -)
            case "${OPTARG}" in
              loglevel)
                  eval val="\$${OPTIND}"; OPTIND=$(( $OPTIND + 1 ))
                  echo "Parsing option: '--${OPTARG}', value: '${val}'" >&2
                  ;;
              loglevel=*)
                  val=${OPTARG#*=}
                  opt=${OPTARG%=$val}
                  echo "Parsing option: '--${opt}', value: '${val}'" >&2
                  ;;
            esac
            ;;
        h)
            echo "usage: $0 [--loglevel[=]<value>]" >&2
            exit 2
            ;;
    esac
done
=== Argbash ===
Line 154: Line 145:
# End of file
}}}
In practice, this example is so obfuscated that it may be preferable to add concatenated option support (like `-vf filename`) to a manual parsing loop instead, if that was the only reason for using `getopts`.
[[https://github.com/matejak/argbash|Argbash]] is a simple-to-use yet feature-rich code generator that can either generate the parsing code for your script, tailor-made. The project features extensive [[http://argbash.readthedocs.io/en/stable/index.html|documentation]].
Line 158: Line 147:
Here's an improved and more generalized version of above attempt to add support for long options when using `getopts`:

{{{#!highlight bash
#!/bin/bash
# Uses bash extensions. Not portable as written.

declare -A longoptspec
longoptspec=( [loglevel]=1 ) #use associative array to declare how many arguments a long option expects, in this case we declare that loglevel expects/has one argument, long options that aren't listed in this way will have zero arguments by default
optspec=":h-:"
while getopts "$optspec" opt; do
while true; do
    case "${opt}" in
        -) #OPTARG is name-of-long-option or name-of-long-option=value
            if [[ "${OPTARG}" =~ .*=.* ]] #with this --key=value format only one argument is possible
            then
                opt=${OPTARG/=*/}
                OPTARG=${OPTARG#*=}
                ((OPTIND--))
            else #with this --key value1 value2 format multiple arguments are possible
                opt="$OPTARG"
                OPTARG=(${@:OPTIND:$((longoptspec[$opt]))})
            fi
            ((OPTIND+=longoptspec[$opt]))
            continue #now that opt/OPTARG are set we can process them as if getopts would've given us long options
            ;;
        loglevel)
          loglevel=$OPTARG
            ;;
        h|help)
            echo "usage: $0 [--loglevel[=]<value>]" >&2
            exit 2
            ;;
    esac
break; done
done

# End of file
}}}
With this version you can have long and short options side by side and you shouldn't need to modify the code from line 10 to 22. This solution can also handle multiple arguments for long options, just use ${OPTARG} or ${OPTARG[0]} for the first argument, ${OPTARG[1]} for the second argument, ${OPTARG[2]} for the third argument and so on. It has the same disadvantage of its predecessor in not being portable and specific to bash. Additionally, it breaks arguments with whitespace (line 18) for long options, when given using the syntax that does not include equal sign (=).

=== Silly repeated brute-force scanning ===
Another approach is to check options with `if` statements "on demand". A function like this one may be useful:
The sample project from above (script accepting a `-f|--file|--verbose|...`) would use the following template:
Line 204: Line 152:
HaveOpt ()
{
    local needle=$1
    shift
# ARG_OPTIONAL_SINGLE([file],[f],[input file])
# ARG_VERBOSE()
# ARG_POSITIONAL_DOUBLEDASH()
# ARG_LEFTOVERS([other args])
# ARGBASH_GO()
Line 209: Line 158:
    while [[ $1 == -* ]]
    do
        # By convention, "--" means end of options.
        case "$1" in
            --) return 1 ;;
            $needle) return 0 ;;
        esac
# [ <-- needed because of Argbash
Line 217: Line 160:
        shift
    done
if [ "$_arg_verbose" -gt 0 ]; then
 echo "Input file: $_arg_file"
 echo "Other args: ${_arg_leftovers[*]}"
fi
Line 220: Line 165:
    return 1
}
# ] <-- needed because of Argbash
}}}
Line 223: Line 168:
HaveOpt --quick "$@" && echo "Option quick is set"

# End of file
}}}
and it will work if script is run as:

 * YES: ./script --quick
 * YES: ./script -other --quick

but will stop on first argument with no "-" in front (or on --):

 * NO: ./script -bar foo --quick
 * NO: ./script -bar -- --quick

Of course, this approach (iterating over the argument list every time you want to check for one) is far less efficient than just iterating once and setting flag variables.

It also spreads the options throughout the program. The literal option `--quick` may appear a hundred lines down inside the main body of the program, nowhere near any other option name. This is a nightmare for maintenance.

=== Complex nonstandard add-on utilities ===
[[http://bhepple.freeshell.org/oddmuse/wiki.cgi/process-getopt|bhepple]] suggests the use of [[http://sourceforge.net/projects/process-getopt/|process-getopt]] (GPL licensed) and offers this example code:
Then, executing the result script as `./script.sh -f my-file --verbose -- one two three --file foo` would yield
Line 245: Line 171:
PROG=$(basename $0)
VERSION='1.2'
USAGE="A tiny example using process-getopt(1)"
    Input file: foo
    other args: one two three
}}}
Line 249: Line 175:
# call process-getopt functions to define some options:
source process-getopt
The project also features a [[http://argbash.readthedocs.io/en/stable/example.html#minimal-example|quickstart utility]] that can generate a minimal template for you like this:
`argbash-init --opt file --pos arg-positional | argbash - -o basic_script.sh && ./basic_script.sh -h`
Line 252: Line 178:
SLOT=""
SLOT_func() { [ "${1:-""}" ] && SLOT="yes"; } # callback for SLOT option
add_opt SLOT "boolean option" s "" slot
{{{
<The general help message of my script>
Usage: ./basic_script.sh [--file <arg>] [-h|--help] <arg-positional>
 <arg-positional>: <arg-positional's help message goes here>
 --file: <file's help message goes here> (no default)
 -h,--help: Prints help
}}}
Line 256: Line 186:
TOKEN=""
TOKEN_func() { [ "${1:-""}" ] && TOKEN="$2"; } # callback for TOKEN option
add_opt TOKEN "this option takes a value" t n token number

add_std_opts # define the standard options --help etc:

TEMP=$(call_getopt "$@") || exit 1
eval set -- "$TEMP" # just as with getopt(1)

# remove the options from the command line
process_opts "$@" || shift "$?"

echo "SLOT=$SLOT"
echo "TOKEN=$TOKEN"
echo "args=$@"
}}}
Here, all information about each option is defined in one place making for much easier authoring and maintenance. A lot of the dirty work is handled automatically and standards are obeyed as in getopt(1) - because it calls getopt for you.

 . ''Actually, what the author forgot to say was that it's actually using `getopts` semantics, rather than `getopt`. I ran this test:''
 {{{
 ~/process-getopt-1.6$ set -- one 'rm -rf /' 'foo;bar' "'"
 ~/process-getopt-1.6$ call_getopt "$@"
  -- 'rm -rf /' 'foo;bar' ''\'''
}}}
 . ''It appears to be intelligent enough to handle null options, whitespace-containing options, and single-quote-containing options in a manner that makes the [[BashFAQ/048|eval]] not blow up in your face. But this is not an endorsement of the process-getopt software overall; I don't know it well enough. -GreyCat ''

''It's written and tested on Linux where getopt(1) supports long options. For portability, it tests the local getopt(1) at runtime and if it finds an non-GNU one (ie one that does not return 4 for {{{getopt --test}}}) it only processes short options. It does not use the bash builtin getopts(1) command. -[[http://bhepple.freeshell.org/oddmuse/wiki.cgi/process-getopt|bhepple]] ''
One can then just fine-tune the template and get a script with argument parsing capabilities with little effort.
Line 285: Line 188:
'' CategoryShell '' CategoryShell

How can I handle command-line arguments (options) to my script easily?

Well, that depends a great deal on what you want to do with them. There are several approaches, each with its strengths and weaknesses.

Manual loop

Manually parsing options without the use of a specialized function is the most flexible approach, and is sufficient for most simple scripts.

This example will handle a combination of short (POSIX) and long "GNU style" options with option arguments. Notice how both --file FILE and --file=FILE are handled. Typical scripts may also use functions and local variables, which can greatly improve your code. This example however illustrates a strictly POSIX conforming script.

   1 #!/bin/sh
   2 # POSIX
   3 
   4 # Reset all variables that might be set
   5 file=
   6 verbose=0 # Variables to be evaluated as shell arithmetic should be initialized to a default or validated beforehand.
   7 
   8 while :; do
   9     case $1 in
  10         -h|-\?|--help)   # Call a "show_help" function to display a synopsis, then exit.
  11             show_help
  12             exit
  13             ;;
  14         -f|--file)       # Takes an option argument, ensuring it has been specified.
  15             if [ -n "$2" ]; then
  16                 file=$2
  17                 shift
  18             else
  19                 printf 'ERROR: "--file" requires a non-empty option argument.\n' >&2
  20                 exit 1
  21             fi
  22             ;;
  23         --file=?*)
  24             file=${1#*=} # Delete everything up to "=" and assign the remainder.
  25             ;;
  26         --file=)         # Handle the case of an empty --file=
  27             printf 'ERROR: "--file" requires a non-empty option argument.\n' >&2
  28             exit 1
  29             ;;
  30         -v|--verbose)
  31             verbose=$((verbose + 1)) # Each -v argument adds 1 to verbosity.
  32             ;;
  33         --)              # End of all options.
  34             shift
  35             break
  36             ;;
  37         -?*)
  38             printf 'WARN: Unknown option (ignored): %s\n' "$1" >&2
  39             ;;
  40         *)               # Default case: If no more options then break out of the loop.
  41             break
  42     esac
  43 
  44     shift
  45 done
  46 
  47 # if --file was provided, open it for writing, else duplicate stdout
  48 if [ -n "$file" ]; then
  49     exec 3> "$file"
  50 else
  51     exec 3>&1
  52 fi
  53 
  54 # Rest of the program here.
  55 # If there are input files (for example) that follow the options, they
  56 # will remain in the "$@" positional parameters.

This parser does not handle separate options concatenated together (like -xvf being understood as -x -v -f). This could be added with effort, but this is left as an exercise for the reader.

getopts

Unless it's the version from util-linux, and you use its advanced mode, never use getopt(1). Traditional versions of getopt cannot handle empty argument strings, or arguments with embedded whitespace.

The POSIX shell (and others) offer getopts which is safe to use instead. Here is a simplistic getopts example:

   1 #!/bin/sh
   2 
   3 # Usage info
   4 show_help() {
   5 cat << EOF
   6 Usage: ${0##*/} [-hv] [-f OUTFILE] [FILE]...
   7 Do stuff with FILE and write the result to standard output. With no FILE
   8 or when FILE is -, read standard input.
   9 
  10     -h          display this help and exit
  11     -f OUTFILE  write the result to OUTFILE instead of standard output.
  12     -v          verbose mode. Can be used multiple times for increased
  13                 verbosity.
  14 EOF
  15 }
  16 
  17 # Initialize our own variables:
  18 output_file=""
  19 verbose=0
  20 
  21 OPTIND=1
  22 # Resetting OPTIND is necessary if getopts was used previously in the script.
  23 # It is a good idea to make OPTIND local if you process options in a function.
  24 
  25 while getopts "hvf:" opt; do
  26     case "$opt" in
  27         h)
  28             show_help
  29             exit 0
  30             ;;
  31         v)  verbose=$((verbose+1))
  32             ;;
  33         f)  output_file=$OPTARG
  34             ;;
  35         '?')
  36             show_help >&2
  37             exit 1
  38             ;;
  39     esac
  40 done
  41 shift "$((OPTIND-1))" # Shift off the options and optional --.
  42 
  43 # Everything that's left in "$@" is a non-option.  In our case, a FILE to process.
  44 printf 'verbose=<%d>\noutput_file=<%s>\nLeftovers:\n' "$verbose" "$output_file"
  45 printf '<%s>\n' "$@"
  46 
  47 # End of file

There is a getopts tutorial which explains what all of the syntax and variables mean. In bash, there is also help getopts, which might be informative.

The advantages of getopts:

  1. It's portable, and will work in any POSIX shell e.g. dash.
  2. It can handle things like -vf filename in the expected Unix way, automatically.

  3. It understands -- as the option terminator and more generally makes sure, options are parsed like for any standard command.

  4. With some implementations, the error messages will be localised in the language of the user.

The disadvantages of getopts:

  1. (Except for ksh93 getopts) it can only handle short options (-h, not --help) without trickery.

  2. It cannot handle options with optional arguments à la GNU.
  3. Options are coded in at least 2, probably 3 places -- in the call to getopts, in the case statement that processes them, and in the help/usage message that documents them.

For other, more complicated ways of option parsing, see ComplexOptionParsing.

Argbash

Argbash is a simple-to-use yet feature-rich code generator that can either generate the parsing code for your script, tailor-made. The project features extensive documentation.

The sample project from above (script accepting a -f|--file|--verbose|...) would use the following template:

   1 #!/bin/bash
   2 
   3 # ARG_OPTIONAL_SINGLE([file],[f],[input file])
   4 # ARG_VERBOSE()
   5 # ARG_POSITIONAL_DOUBLEDASH()
   6 # ARG_LEFTOVERS([other args])
   7 # ARGBASH_GO()
   8 
   9 # [ <-- needed because of Argbash
  10 
  11 if [ "$_arg_verbose" -gt 0 ]; then
  12         echo "Input file: $_arg_file"
  13         echo "Other args: ${_arg_leftovers[*]}"
  14 fi
  15 
  16 # ] <-- needed because of Argbash

Then, executing the result script as ./script.sh -f my-file --verbose -- one two three --file foo would yield

    Input file: foo
    other args: one two three

The project also features a quickstart utility that can generate a minimal template for you like this: argbash-init --opt file --pos arg-positional | argbash - -o basic_script.sh && ./basic_script.sh -h

<The general help message of my script>
Usage: ./basic_script.sh [--file <arg>] [-h|--help] <arg-positional>
        <arg-positional>: <arg-positional's help message goes here>
        --file: <file's help message goes here> (no default)
        -h,--help: Prints help

One can then just fine-tune the template and get a script with argument parsing capabilities with little effort.


CategoryShell

BashFAQ/035 (last edited 2024-02-26 07:51:38 by larryv)